Skip Navigation

Replacement Plug for Toddy Maker

$2.50

$5 Flat Fee for Standard Shipping

Free Shipping on Orders Over $50

Replacement rubber plugs for Toddy Maker, because they are small and might get lost.

Fresh coffee means your order will take a few days to ship from our roastery. If you place an order on the weekend, it will not be processed until Monday. Don’t fret, you’ll get an email update when your box of happiness is on the way!

Shipping & return information

default avatar

We’ve been customers since the beginning, have loved them all, Morning Glory, Birchwood, Twin Cities, Peruvian, and my hubby loves all the dark roasts. We make gifts of them and wouldn’t drink anyone else’s coffee.

— Susan F.
default avatar

I got my first bag of coffee in the mail yesterday. It smelled so amazing 🤤 I just took my first sip and it tastes just as good as it smells ❤️!

— April D.

you might like

bag of cold brew coffee beans

Yeti Cold Brew

Smooth & Creamy
$12$64

Grind Type

Toddy Maker

$38

Let's be friends.

Love coffee with us!


shopping cart icon View Cart