by
Tripp Pomeroy
Though it's easy to complain about the electoral
process here in the United States, we actually have it
good. We live in a country where we have the opportunity
to choose our leaders. But given our busy lives,
over-saturation with information and spin, and the
plethora of differing points of view and convictions,
it’s easy to get distracted from the task at hand…to
make our elections work well and effect change for the
better.
In 2002, President Jimmy Carter traveled to East Timor
to observe and support the country’s first presidential
elections, which would culminate in the birth of this
century’s first new nation — the Republic of East
Timor. In its analysis "The East Timor Political and
Election Observation Project" the Carter Center
identified several areas that it believed were central to
the new country’s ability to pull off credible,
effective elections; they were: the security situation;
the behavior and relationship between parties and
candidates; citizens’ knowledge of the electoral
process; the role of domestic observers and political
party agents in each election; and women’s political
participation in the transition.
As November 2nd fast approaches, I thought it might be
helpful (and hopefully inspiring) to break-down our
election process into the components identified by the
Carter Center vis-à-vis the elections in East Timor to
see how we are doing. After all, any monumental task is
always better managed and more likely successful when it
is dissected and its building blocks tackled individually.
Security –
Despite what the pundits and media are saying about
national security and the potential threat to our safety
in the upcoming elections, we are, relatively speaking, in
great shape. I don’t think it would be an exaggeration
to say that nobody in this country need fear traveling to
their polling station to place his or her vote.
The behavior and relationship
between parties and candidates – Well,
perhaps this is an area in which we aren’t so evolved.
When it comes to the parties’ and candidate’s behavior
and their relationship to each other as well as the
public, it seems that there is much work to do in the
United States. Campaign reform has never been more sorely
lacking and further, the party machines seem to have
forgotten that the single most important reason for their
existence is not to win – it is to work with others to
make our country a better place for all citizens. I’m
not saying that winning isn’t important, it is if the
parties are to have their voice in policy, but, the
extreme polarization of the executive and legislative and
even the judicial branches at times, is short-circuiting
the process. Differences in opinion need to be harnessed
rather than manipulated in order to come together in the
best interest of the common good rather than serve as a
reason to divide and pit one against another.
Citizen’s knowledge of the
electoral process – Ouch! With perhaps the
best access to information in the world, it is astounding
that we are so uneducated about our system and how it
works. In defense of voters though, I needed weeks to
prepare for the last elections when I lived in Florida —
the length of the ballot, the number of candidates and
issues and the seemingly bottomless depth to the
ramifications of each vote I cast were nothing short of
daunting. On the other hand, how lucky I was to have so
many choices and a forum in which to express my opinion.
But there is work to be done on our own education —
parents, teachers and other role models (not to mention
politicians) need to proactively communicate to our fellow
citizens the basics — how the system works and why
voting is a responsibility to be taken seriously — in a
non-partisan manner. The mass media needs to perform more
in-depth analyses of our election mechanics and report on
our performance as the Carter Center does all around the
world. Telling people to get out and vote isn’t enough,
especially in light of the discouraging behavior and
relationship between parties and candidates in the US.
Issue-driven voting alone is also a problem — voting
within the context of making the US and the world more
just, healthy and peaceful is paramount.
One suggestion I have heard, which would give voters a
little extra time and motivation to take the vote
seriously, would be to turn election day into a national
holiday as do so many other countries around the world.
For those who say we can’t spare another holiday, just
swap it out with Columbus Day, a misinformed celebration
of a man who was the very antithesis of what our election
system stands for.
The role of domestic observers
and political agents in each election — how
about a recognized, external national ombudsman for each
of our national elections or even better, giving due
attention to the many that already exist. Observers and
respect for their role in, yes, monitoring our elections,
would be a major advance in our system, especially given
the very nature of "political agents" – which
is exactly what they are and what they do…it’s their
job. If observers can help East Timor pull off successful
elections, surely they can help us do the same.
Women’s political
participation in the transition — This is an
area in which I believe we have a unique opportunity.
Women have made such huge strides in this country over the
past century, serving as an inspiration to the
disenfranchised around the world. Our biggest challenge
now is to vote women into the top, executive echelons of
our government. The time for a woman President or Vice
President came long ago…let’s shake it up and make it
happen.
Though this is a very brief take on this year’s
election, it is a fact that we are truly fortunate to have
country in which voting is safe and a consistent component
of our national life. We are well-equipped to make our
electoral system succeed, with so many great tools like
information, free media, the participation and leadership
of women and the presence of observers willing to make our
system work more effectively. Putting all of these
resources to use is what I perceive to be the greatest
challenge at hand. Our preoccupation with winning, being
right, making others wrong and vilifying those with whom
we disagree has become an all consuming distraction.
If the good people of East Timor can make it work,
certainly we can too. So, instead of detracting from the
process by dwelling on its shortcomings and defects, we
should count our blessings and make the most of them. East
Timor’s successful elections — which literally started
from scratch — should inspire us to get out and vote and
do what is necessary to make the system work. Every vote
counts…imagine what our lives would be like if they
didn’t.